A public spat broke out between Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah and his predecessor Mehbooba Mufti on social media on Friday over calls for revival of the Tulbul Navigation project after the suspension of the Indus Waters Treaty.
Ms Mufti accused Mr Abdullah of adopting "provocative" measures amid ongoing tensions between India and Pakistan. Mr Abdullah, however, alleged that the former Chief Minister was trying to score "cheap publicity points" and "please some people" in Pakistan by opposing the idea.
The Tulbul Navigation project - that seeks to rejuvenate the Jhelum-fed Wular lake in Bandipora district - was launched in 1987 but paused in 2007 amid objections from Pakistan that it violated the Indus Waters Treaty. With India suspending the Treaty on April 23, a day after the Pahalgam terror attack, Mr Abdullah on Thursday called for resumption of work in the project on Wular Lake.
In a post on X, the Chief Minister said that since the water pact with Pakistan has been kept in abeyance, "I wonder if we will be able to resume the project".
"The Wular lake in North Kashmir. The civil works you see in the video is the Tulbul Navigation Barrage. It was started in the early 1980s but had to be abandoned under pressure from Pakistan citing the Indus Water Treaty," he wrote on the micro-blogging platform.
The Wular lake in North Kashmir. The civil works you see in the video is the Tulbul Navigation Barrage. It was started in the early 1980s but had to be abandoned under pressure from Pakistan citing the Indus Water Treaty. Now that the IWT has been “temporarily suspended” I… pic.twitter.com/MQbGSXJKvq
— Omar Abdullah (@OmarAbdullah) May 15, 2025
The National Conference leader said that if completed, the Tulbul project can help in using the Jhelum river for navigation purposes. "It will give us the advantage of allowing us to use the Jhelum for navigation. It will also improve the power generation of downstream power projects, especially in winter," he added.
Under the Indus Waters Treaty governing six common rivers, all the water of the eastern rivers - Sutlej, Beas, and Ravi amounting to around 33 million acre feet (MAF) annually - has been allocated to India for unrestricted use. The waters of western rivers - Indus, Jhelum, and Chenab - amounting to around 135 MAF annually have been assigned largely to Pakistan.
Ms Mufti, however, launched a scathing attack on Mr Abdullah and labelled his call as "irresponsible and dangerously provocative".
The Chief Minister's call to revive the Tulbul Navigation Project amid tensions between India and Pakistan is "deeply unfortunate", she said in a post on X. "At a time when both countries have just stepped back from the brink of a full-fledged war - with Jammu and Kashmir bearing the brunt through the loss of innocent lives, widespread destruction and immense suffering - such statements are not only irresponsible but also dangerously provocative," she said.
The Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) chief said the people of the Union Territory deserve peace as much as anyone else in the country. "Weaponising something as essential and life-giving as water is not only inhumane but also risks internationalising what should remain a bilateral matter," she said.
J&K Chief Minister Omar Abdullah's call to revive the Tulbul Navigation Project amid ongoing tensions between India & Pakistan is deeply unfortunate. At a time when both countries have just stepped back from the brink of a full-fledged war—with Jammu and Kashmir bearing the brunt… https://t.co/LZrVAhIukQ
— Mehbooba Mufti (@MehboobaMufti) May 16, 2025
The former Chief Minister's comments evoked a sharp response from Mr Abdullah, who accused her of attempting to "please some people across the border".
"Actually what is unfortunate is that with your blind lust to try to score cheap publicity points and please some people sitting across the border, you refuse to acknowledge that the IWT has been one of the biggest historic betrayals of the interests of the people of J&K," he told his rival.
"I have always opposed this treaty and I will continue to do so. Opposing a blatantly unfair treaty is in no way, shape, size or form warmongering, it's about correcting a historic injustice that denied the people of J&K the right to use our water for ourselves," he added.
Actually what is unfortunate is that with your blind lust to try to score cheap publicity points & please some people sitting across the border, you refuse to acknowledge that the IWT has been one of the biggest historic betrayals of the interests of the people of J&K. I have… https://t.co/j55YwE2r39
— Omar Abdullah (@OmarAbdullah) May 16, 2025
Time will reveal who seeks to appease whom, Ms Mufti said in response, as the back-and-forth continued. "However, it's worth recalling that your esteemed grandfather Sheikh Sahab once advocated for accession to Pakistan for over two decades after losing power. But post being reinstated as Chief Minister he suddenly reversed his stance by aligning with India," she said.
On the contrary, she added, the PDP has consistently upheld its convictions and commitments, unlike the NC whose loyalties have shifted dramatically according to political expediency.
"We don't need to stoke tensions or adopt warmongering rhetoric to validate our dedication. Our actions speak for themselves," she said.
Time will reveal who seeks to appease whom. However, it's worth recalling that your esteemed grandfather Sheikh Sahab once advocated for accession to Pakistan for over two decades after losing power. But post being reinstated as Chief Minister he suddenly reversed his stance by… https://t.co/2jSBku731K
— Mehbooba Mufti (@MehboobaMufti) May 16, 2025
Mr Abdullah told Ms Mufti that she can keep "advocating the interests of anyone you want to & I'll keep advocating for the interests of the people of J&K to use our own rivers for our own benefit".
"Is that really the best you can do? Taking cheap shots at a person you yourself have called Kashmir's tallest leader. I'll rise above the gutter you want to take this conversation to by keeping the late Mufti Sahib and 'North Pole South Pole' out of this," he said.
"I'm not going to stop the water, just use more of it for ourselves. Now I think I'll do some real work & you can keep posting," he added.
Is that really the best you can do? Taking cheap shots at a person you yourself have called Kashmir's tallest leader. I'll rise above the gutter you want to take this conversation to by keeping the late Mufti Sahib and “North Pole South Pole” out of this. You keep advocating the… https://t.co/R6wGL2o4tL
— Omar Abdullah (@OmarAbdullah) May 16, 2025
In a separate post later, the Chief Minister shared a news report from 2016, which quoted Ms Mufti as saying that "Jammu and Kashmir has suffered due to the Indus Waters Treaty". "Just leaving this out there because "consistency" is in such short supply," he said.
Just leaving this out there because “consistency” is in such short supply. pic.twitter.com/jn9x2zAqwS
— Omar Abdullah (@OmarAbdullah) May 16, 2025
To this, Ms Mufti clarified that she has never sought scrapping of the water pact. "Such a move could heighten tensions and once again place Jammu and Kashmir at the epicenter of conflict. Our resources like water must be used for life, not as weapons. You invoking IWT now is a reckless ploy to derail the ceasefire," she said, adding "there's nothing patriotic about fueling instability".
"PDP has consistently called for the return of power projects that NC handed over to NHPC (National Hydroelectric Power Corporation Limited) on a platter at a pittance. Even in the PDP-BJP Agenda of Alliance, it was agreed that two projects would be returned to Jammu & Kashmir to compensate for losses from the Indus Waters Treaty," she said.
PDP has consistently called for the return of power projects that NC handed over to NHPC on a platter at a pittance.
— Mehbooba Mufti (@MehboobaMufti) May 16, 2025
Even in the PDP-BJP Agenda of Alliance, it was agreed that two projects would be returned to Jammu & Kashmir to compensate for losses from the Indus Waters… https://t.co/YTHZgf91mx pic.twitter.com/U2MByggqYW
As per the Indus Waters Treaty, signed on September 19, 1960, India has the right to generate hydroelectricity through run of the river projects on the western rivers subject to specific criteria for design and operation. Pakistan has the right to raise objections on the design of Indian hydroelectric projects on western rivers.
Relations between India and Pakistan, that took a nosedive in 2019 with the revocation of Article 370 in Jammu and Kashmir, deteriorated further after the Pahalgam terror attack. India responded by launching Operation Sindoor, targeting nine terror bases in Pakistan and PoK. This escalated tensions as it led to strikes and counter-strikes between the two nations. On May 10, India and Pakistan reached an agreement to stop all firing and military action on land, air and sea.
Track Latest News Live on NDTV.com and get news updates from India and around the world
